McCaffery’s Bar

Reviews

• Elysia P.

  star star star star star 10 October 2026

  I've been going here for the last 10 years for one thing, fish and chips!
  This bar has the best fish and chips in all of downriver. I'd love to see someone challenge this. Suggestions are welcome. I still am skeptical I'd find something better. The homemade tartar sauce is an amazing compliment to the fish. I make of point of coming at least once during lent.
  The service has always been great. The atmosphere is fun and friendly. I've gone here with friends, with my Grandma, and with my parents. All ages (over 21) appear to be welcome.

• Ali S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 4 October 2026

  I recently moved to the neighborhood and decided to try this for the first time. On the building it say "$2 long islands every day" so i ordered a Long Island with my dinner. It was delicious so I ordered a second. When I received my bill, I was charged $5 for each Long Island. When I asked the waitress about it, she said that I didn't specifically ask for the "$2 Long Island" so I had to pay the price for the regular Long Island. I explained that it was my first time and it didn't say anything on the sign about "asking specifically" so she said she would ask for me and even after she asked the bartender/owner, they didn't even come over and she said I had to pay the $10 since I had received the regular Long Island instead of the "premade" ones for $2. I could not believe the TERRIBLE customer service!!!! That waitress didn't mention a word about having a $2 or regular Long Island when I ordered and yet they didn't apologize nor even offer any discount considering it was my first time. So frustrating but I paid and left because I really had no choice or even decent service. I will never be going back again.

• Jim D.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 1 October 2026

  Very cold inside. Always new waitresses been going there for two years on wed night. Bills are always incorrect. Have to send food back unfit for human consumption

• Tanya H.

  star star star star star 27 September 2026

  Love their soups. Nachos were really good as well

• Rodrigo T.

  star star star star star_border 25 September 2026

  Ok,, fine,, I'll do a review of the bar.
  
  Only because my fiance likes to come here. To grab a few drinks while killing time. YES I AM A Lincoln Parker and idgaf.
  
  No, it's not a posh spot. And no it's not the snooty joint. So do not, I repeat, Do NOT assume that this spot is gonna transform into a trendy speak easy or a hipster joint. It's your neighborhood bar,,, PERIOD.
  
  There's been a few updates, like the blue lights and the outside has that whole modern thing going on. The bathroom has been redone as well. I definitely applaud the waterless urinals. I love it when a bar is all about saving trees.
  
  Beer is beer,,, bar food is bar food,, but the service is very good. Never have I ever had a bad experience. It's a no B.S. spot and I'm all about no B.S.
  
  Thank you for reading my review. I hope this helps. Enjoy your awesome yelptastic day!!!